He very definitely told your father theres a chance a very great chance he said that Seymour may completely lose control of himself. J.D. Salinger. A soldiers life is one of hardships. Seen as the pride of a nation they are tasked with defending the honour of their motherland with both flesh and blood. A life that requires chivalry discipline and steadfastness. Their existence serves as a beacon light to the tame and cowardly a source of inspiration for the youth to grow strong. But underneath all the glory and medallions reveal a darker tale more telling of their lives. Ordinary people before donning a uniform and sent off to war a life of violence and suffering entails them. A hellish nightmare seeming to never end makes it near impossible to return to their former self. One must be physically and mentally tough to ever hope to survive such a turbulent time but not everyone is capable of carrying that weight. J.D. Salinger was one writer who certainly understood the pressures put upon people in severe circumstances such as war through firsthand experience being drafted into the US army in 1942 even being hospitalized by combat stress reaction months after Germany was defeated in World War II. He was clearly affected going so far as stating he found it impossible to fit into a society that ignored the truth that he now knew. These events all informed his writing of the short story titled A Perfect Day for Bananafish. While numerous interpretations of the story do exist the common belief is that it symbolizes those soldiers sent off to war and came back traumatized gorged by the anguish brought on from war and stained of bloodshed. Decades later this short story would be loosely referenced to in the successful shoujo manga series Banana Fish written and illustrated by Akimi Yoshida that would later be considered highly influential to the BL subgenre. And now over 20 years since the mangas initial release Banana Fish received an anime adaptation produced courtesy by Studio MAPPA to run for 24 episodes in the latter half of 2018. Banana Fish focuses on the relationship between Ash Lynx a cold ruthless teenage gang leader in New York City and a nave assistant photographer from Japan in Eiji Okumura. Both men despite appearing as polar opposites in personality and upbringing end up being caught in a fallout over an entity known as Banana Fish that also happens to be related to Ashs brother and what occurred on his stint in Iraq. The pursuit of this mystery further pulls Eiji to the centre of this conflict thereby leading to Ash pushing against the wishes of his bosses and gang members who put the safety of his newfound friend in jeopardy. It would be easy to summarize the story as simply a developing romance between two men but the series is more concerned in making the story and overarching weight of it at the forefront of the tale causing the narrative despite being heavily reliant on genre tropes works effectively as a fastpaced charming thriller. The series uses heavy topics regarding drugs sexual abuse corruption and other mature themes to craft a careful drama that avoids sensationalizing the sheer brutality inherent with such subject matter. Likewise these ideas further accentuate the thematic correlation between Salingers A Perfect Day for Bananafish and this loosely inspired adaptation. No other character is as carefully crafted nor developed to the same degree as the main protagonist Ash Lynx. His backstory alone would be enough to garner the sympathy of many: a boy who ran away from home at 8 years old only to be taken into custody by the head of the Mafia. Having been kidnapped as a sex slave numerous times later before being granted leadership of a street gang years later he has seen his fair share of violence and trauma. Part of his likability derives from him never seeing himself as a victim and therefore is able to overcome adversity. However his meeting of Eiji is what ultimately acts as the cause for Ash to slowly reveal himself emotionally and properly recover from trauma accumulated throughout the years. His character easily parallels that of Salingers protagonist as someone who has been exposed to so much that the idea of recovering from it all is improbable. Both of these characters take a liking to their more innocent counterparts seeing in them what they once had but now have lost for reasons that were outside of their control. Clinging to that one person in the hope to keep them sane and in the case of Banana Fish no matter how the world might see Ash Eiji will remain by his side. But similarly to Salingers short tale it may not be enough to help Ash change to a more civil lifestyle. Despite the original manga being set in the 1980s Studio MAPPA decided to move the setting to a more modern time and as such caused various changes to the anime that deviate from the original source. Some of the most obvious examples include using character designs typical of the current animation standards rather that the originals welldefined character models and the implementation of technology such as smartphones used by the majority of the cast. These changes whilst they may come off slightly offputting are fairly harmless in the grand scheme of things. Although when it comes to contemporizing the story and its themes there are numerous issues that arise. For example by revising the setting to present day many of the topics covered can be considered outdated and requires a certain suspension of disbelief not to lose any immersion the viewer has with the world established. This take also renders most of the social commentary the original story had as nearly obsolete which was one of the aspects that made the manga so important for its time. Its something that most viewers probably wouldnt have a problem with as it still remains a piece of fiction that can be enjoyed without social context. But for those that want to look at this show deeper that the ordinary fan its an issue that can easily cause disappointment amongst certain anime fans. Another key issue that I personally had throughout watching was how many elements regarding the plot and characters slowly become narrowed as the series continues. Allow me to elaborate the beginning of this show was really appealing not only on a visual level with how vibrant the settings were and the distinct designs on display but with how many different parts there was to the plotline. From the main characters to the supporting cast gang members to the numerous villains to everyone else involved each of these groups felt like their own intricate parts to the storyline that had the potential to create something truly special. But as the plot continues it becomes apparent that the storyline is only meant to focus on the relationship between Ash and Eiji. This is not necessarily a bad thing Banana Fish revolves around this in particular. But I cant help but feel disappointed when a show with so many moving parts to begin with are funnelled out to prioritize all the screen time on the core plotline. Especially if comparing the anime to the manga which gave more balanced attention to the large cast of characters intertwined. The villains all had varying degrees of depth but none of which I would honestly call complex most characters not associated with a gang are shafted halfway through the anime and the gang members that are fleshed out are always given time and focus corresponding to their relationship with Ash. This is not a severe knock against the show but I cant help it when I see a series like Banana Fish have so much potential and not seriously capitalize upon it. The visuals for Banana Fish are a solid outing for Studio MAPPA. While I have my personal preference for character designs the animation present here is energetic in how it depicts character movements and expressions as well as providing the audience with some very exciting action scenes. The dynamic colour palette and background art are both visually appealing that while some might consider it detrimental to the tone of the show I believe do better to initially attract anime fans to the series in general acting as a pleasant treat for the eyes at first glance. The framing of the most controversial events that took place in Banana Fish was also commendable in giving the series a good sense of artistry. The audio for Banana Fish is also praiseworthy with strong performances for voice acting overall really capturing the essence of each main character. The soundtrack also fits most scenes well despite none particularly standing out except for the OP and ED tracks which is just simply fun to listen to. No matter what your music taste these tracks are pretty accessible and make for fun openers to each episode. The translations however could definitely act as a detriment to the series as a whole depending on your take of the sensitive topics covered in Banana Fish. Personally I found it funny when Ash calls a separate character a fag in the translation considering what the series is about but some could easily take such as a homophobic slur and the anime as a whole as tonedeaf. Just be careful what youre getting yourself into k? : Looking back on Banana Fish I see a series with a lot of upside to it. A carefully handled crime drama innovative for its time critically acclaimed source material etc. And despite having my own criticisms against the series I would still recommend this to anyone interested in the series at all. Despite creative liberties it is at its core a wellmade drama with emotionally powerful moments that are likely to entrance you in a tale barely brought to light by anime. There may be homoerotic undertones present but the series was not made solely for such. Instead it clearly values a strong appreciation for storytelling for that is how people from all different backgrounds can relate to fiction at a fundamental level.